Callaghan’s righteous fury - Big Hero 6 - Rewrite
🚨 Spoiler Alert! 🚨 Everything that follows is spoiler territory, of course…
HIRO
Tadashi... you just let him die...
CALLAGHAN
Give me the mask, Hiro.
HIRO
He went in there to save you!
CALLAGHAN
THAT WAS HIS MISTAKE!
Why does Callaghan harm others, when his beef is solely with Alistair Krei?
Tadashi was Callaghan’s star pupil, his beloved protege. Even if psychopathic, how can he be so indifferent, inconsistent with his initial scene?
Big Hero 6 is beloved for its emotional heart of Baymax and the brothers. But it is widely discredited for being among the worst offenders of a “Disney twist villain” in Professor Robert Callaghan.
I’m still trying to figure out the crucial element of these unpopular twist villains, like Hans (Frozen) and Evelyn Deavor (Incredibles 2). Because growing up, we’ve got a lot of great twist villains:
- Waternoose (Monsters Inc.)
- Stinky Pete and Lotso (Toy Story)
- Carl Muntz (Up)
- Turbo (Wreck-it-Ralph)
- Hernesto (Coco)
What makes a good or bad twist villain? My hypothesis is that the same rules apply with plot twists in mystery novels especially: consistency and continuity.
Callaghan having a daughter wasn’t revealed until the 66% mark, though that
#TODO explore twist villains, in two paragraphs or less
That’s the hypothesis, at least.
What if?
Since the theme of BH6 is of releasing grudges and choosing healing instead of personal revenge, let’s lean into that. Can we flip this on its head, and even make Callaghan into a direct foil for Hiro?
- WHAT IF Alistair Krei started the fire that killed Tadashi, not Callaghan?
- WHAT IF Callaghan saw Tadashi like his own son, and took his loss exactly like losing Abigail?
- WHAT IF Callaghan tempted Hiro to join him in his vendetta for personal revenge against Krei for the losses of Tadashi and Abigail?
- WHAT IF in the climax, Callaghan knocks Krei into the portal too, so Hiro must choose between saving Krei or Baymax?
The Rewrite
Establishing alternate Callaghan
Before the movie even begins: WHAT IF Callaghan had always personally confided in Tadashi, so Tadashi (unlike the other students in the gang) is well aware of Callaghan’s thirst for revenge against Alistair Krei (because Krei’s failed project caused the loss of Abigail). In between their research work, Callaghan would vent his dark fantasies to his mentee.
But Tadashi, the pure-hearted paragon of the story, kept trying to placate Callaghan against rash violence. Perhaps the court trial for Abigail’s accident was taking longer, since it had to follow proper legal procedures. Perhaps Krei has hired expensive defence lawyers. Perhaps Abigail’s case was truly a clear accident.
And Callaghan is placated, for years. Tadashi is sort of like Abigail’s voice, pleading her father to make the right choice. Perhaps Callaghan starts to advise Tadashi in developing Baymax, symbolising Callaghan’s focus on advancing healthcare, instead of plotting revenge.
The first eighth of the movie is as the original. Hiro is illegal bot fighting, so Tadashi takes his brother to San Fransokyo’s Institute of Technology. They briefly meet the gang, Baymax, and Professor Callaghan. There’s a public exhibition where Hiro needs to present his microbots to get accepted by the school’s board.
Alistair Krei (big tech CEO) makes an unexpected appearance and takes interest in Hiro’s microbots. Callaghan is aggressively defensive, we just think his values of inventive integrity doesn’t want his students to sell out to Big Tech.
Tadashi takes Hiro outside and amicably summarises that Callaghan is hot-tempered because he is still grieving the loss of his only daughter (without details, could pass as unimportant lore), but that also meant that Callaghan can provide full attention to help him with Baymax. And Baymax was impossible without Callaghan.
Blaming Alistair Krei
Suddenly, a fire breaks out. Everyone escapes, but Tadashi goes back in for Callaghan. asdsad
As far as Hiro and the audience knows, at this point, Tadashi died in a freak accident.
After the funeral, Hiro learns that there’s some evidence of tampered arson: the chemical storage room’s access door recorded an entry, right before the incident. Sympathetic detectives tell the grieving Hiro to report any suspects only when he is ready.
The next quarter of the story is as the original. Hiro wakes Baymax, and his sole remaining microbot guides them to a hidden lab where thousands of microbots are being made. A man in a kabuki mask (Callaghan, the Yokai) appears, and chases them away.
He prepares Baymax for combat, and heads to the harbour. They get beaten by the Yokai. Tadashi’s friends come in to save him, driving away in a car.
Hiding out at Fred’s mansion, they realise that the Yokai’s locations all connect to Krei Tech. They accuse Alistair Krei and construct his motivations for the fire. The gang tells Hiro that Professor Callaghan had constantly denied him access to the latest tech being developed by bright students. The microbots are lucrative tech. The fire is a great accident cover.
Krei is evil. He is responsible for the deaths of Tadashi, their friend who selflessly cared for others, and Callaghan, their professor who protected their work from evil tech moguls.
They’re riled up. They’re 100% right.
Well, 99% — someone else is the Yokai.
The gang suits up for combat, and prepares to storm Krei’s latest location at an abandoned Krei Tech laboratory.
They find Alistair Krei there. No surprise, that’s his place.
But then the Yokai appears and attacks Alistair Krei. They are not the same person.
Maybe Krei has some of his own tech to defend himself and fight. That would be cool to see.
The gang is shocked at their incorrect accusation, and they attack the hostile Yokai to defend Krei. After a long fight, they sufficiently deplete the microbots.
Finally, the Yokai relents and reveals he is Callaghan.
With Krei and Callaghan subdued by the gang, Callaghan reveals what really happened during the fire in a flashback.
Secrets in the Fire
WHAT IF at the school’s showcase, after Tadashi and Hiro leave, Callaghan tracked Krei (to warn him to stay away from his students, or something) but found him sneaking into a restricted chemical storage room.
Callaghan confronts Krei in the room, and finds him releasing flammable gas throughout the vents. Krei holds up a microbot that he swiped. He admits to desiring to steal Hiro’s microbots tech, using an accidental fire as a cover story.
They brawl as the gas spreads throughout the building’s ventilation system. Callaghan eventually manages to wrest the microbot from Krei. Sensing his defeat, Krei escapes (via an improved version of the teleportation tech that Abigail was experimenting?).
Krei has to escape without the microbot. Callaghan has one microbot in hand, and a building about to combust.
Callaghan sprints out the building’s exit, just as glass windows blow from the first combustion. The building starts billowing flames and smoke.
Callaghan had come out from the back exit, and no one had seen him since everyone was in the showcase and was evacuating from the main front entrance.
Callaghan runs to the front, unnoticed in the chaos. He turns the corner just in time to see Tadashi mouth something to Hiro, then run into the building—then the building explodes in a great ball of fire.
Callaghan ducks behind a bush, horrified, and looks down to the microbot in his hand. Though he didn’t start the fire, Callaghan decides to use it to exact his revenge on the monster who took his daughter—and also his son.
So when Tadashi dies in the explosion, Callaghan loses his last tether to morality. No one keeps him in check anymore. Callaghan, like Hiro, is primed for revenge.
Now, Callaghan goes from being guilty of caring too little for Tadashi (leaving a sour taste in the audience’s mouths), instead he is guilty of caring too much for Tadashi. Just like Hiro.
His crime was not that he cared too little, nay—that he cared too much.
The Temptation
Callaghan explained he faked his death so that he could have free reign to not get caught when going after Krei. He had to fight Hiro’s gang because they risked exposing his plot to the authorities. Perhaps he didn’t want them caught up in his all-consuming thirst for vengeance.
But now that they know his identity, he realises that they are strong, but more importantly: they are all grieving Tadashi.
Crucially, instead of antagonising Hiro, WHAT IF Callaghan makes the opposite offer: join him on his revenge mission.
He shows evidence that Krei was responsible for the fire. Then and there, Krei even admits it, sneering at the weakness of “good men” like Tadashi.
Hiro and Tadashi’s friends all have a glimmer of vitriol and bloodlust.
That’s when Hiro gives in, siccs Baymax on Kill Mode, joining forces with Callaghan to kill Krei. Krei pathetically barely edges his survival, for seconds at a time.
But then maybe the gang have a resolve of heart. They protect Krei against the duo, a 2v4, excluding a beaten and scampering Krei.
Ultimately, Krei gets away safely and Callaghan has to flee the scene (like in the original). Maybe Krei beats Callaghan badly and gets away.
Could we work a consequence into this? Fred gets hurt? i dunnoh
The Final Act
During the 75% Dark Night of the Soul, Baymax shows Hiro a recording of Tadashi, causing Hiro to regret revenge, and decide to defend Krei against Callaghan.
As the climactic fight begins at Krei Tech HQ, Callaghan ambushes Krei and destroys his tech. Callaghan had opened a portal to swallow Krei HQ. Hiro’s gang arrives and defeats Callaghan, just like the original climax.
WHAT IF Callaghan knocks Alistair Krei into the collapsing portal.
This happens before detecting Abigail’s vitals within the portal, before there’s any obvious decision to enter the dangerous dimension to retrieve an innocent person.
After defeating Callaghan, the heroes need to choose: risking their lives to save an innocent is a no-brainer. But will they risk their lives to save an evil man to face proper justice?
Hiro decides he will at least try.
It is because of this decision, to try to save Krei, and scan for Alistair’s life signal in the portal, that Baymax actually reports two life signals.
Alistair Krei… and Abigail Callaghan.
Hiro goes in with Baymax, and reach both unconscious people. That’s four of them, ready to make their safe return through the portal.
Then debris hits and damages Baymax’s flight system.
Baymax reports that his thrusters only have enough power for three out of the four of them can return. One of them must stay behind.
Hiro looks to the unconscious Alistair Krei. Greedy scheming rat who set fire to a building and killed his brother, just for profits.
Baymax replays the video of Tadashi. Hiro is struck to the core.
Hiro is faced with a painful dilemma. To leave the evil businessman floating in a formless void, his just due. Or, to leave behind Baymax, the last remnant of his heroic and selfless brother?
Hiro chooses courageously.
As the portal closes, three bodies narrowly shoot out from within. One robot short.
resources
Big Hero Six - Story Structure Database
helpingwritersbecomeauthors.com